Acoustic Guitar / critique needed...

[daniel481]

It is a nice piece of music, but I believe the listing is definitely calling for a more organic sound. Is it the one that mentions David Gray without the vocals? If so, I would check out some of his music to see what they mean. And as much as the samples might sound very close to an nylon string acoustic, it just doesn't sound like fingers playing against strings. Unfortunately, it just sounds like a keyboard playing samples of a nylon string guitar...which it is To your credit, it does sound a lot closer than many I've heard. It's really, really hard to fake a guitar on a keyboard (I don't know that I've ever been fooled, to be honest). Another thought I had is that the melody you wrote might sound good played through a different patch such as a dulcimer (which is a lot easier to fake, in my opinion). That obviously wouldn't fly for this listing, but it might for something else. Just an idea.HTH,Dan

[silvercord]

Roadrunner yeah i think its the attack of the string that maybe sparks some us fellow classical/nylon guitar players to raise their eyebrowsim listening to it again and mostly notice it on the string plucks with the loudest dynamics..i bet if those few notes were toned down you'd be able topass for an even more authentic sound.