Page 1 of 2
Teeny Pop for S111209PO - feedback please!
Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2011 4:32 pm
by NeilEbanks
Any comments, feedback , suggestions are welcome. Thanks peeps.
The song is "You're no fun" on my TAXI page.
Re: Teeny Pop for S111209PO - feedback please!
Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2011 4:33 pm
by NeilEbanks
I guess the address helps.
www.taxi.com/neilebanks

Re: Teeny Pop for S111209PO - feedback please!
Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2011 7:18 pm
by DavidT
Certainly fits the genre to my ears. At first I thought something was missing until I realised the vocal wasn't drowning in autotune.

Re: Teeny Pop for S111209PO - feedback please!
Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2011 8:13 pm
by burpo
Sounds like a Disney Channel version of Avril Levigne.
Spot on, methinks!
Re: Teeny Pop for S111209PO - feedback please!
Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2011 9:04 pm
by pedrocosta
Hey Neil,
I listened a couple of times and here are my impressions:
The style, arrangement, instrumentation are spot on IMO.
The vocal gets a bit tiring, let me explain. I think the singer is perfect, but the production/effect on the voice could use some switching/variation in the chorus.
And in the "no fun" part I think more voice tracks would be great (gang vocal)
After that a tad more polish on the mix/master.
Just my opinion, please take with grain of salt

Re: Teeny Pop for S111209PO - feedback please!
Posted: Fri Dec 09, 2011 10:05 pm
by NeilEbanks
Hey Pedro. Thanks for the feedback. Extra ears with fresh perspective is always welcome. I will certainly consider your advice.
Burpo, a Disney Avril is exactly what I was going for. LOL. Thanks.
David, I actually tuned the crap out of her. It took me about 3 hours. But not with Autotune. I'm a Melodyne "do it manually" user. Thanks for the comments!!
Re: Teeny Pop for S111209PO - feedback please!
Posted: Sat Dec 10, 2011 4:57 am
by nick.moxsom
Hey, Neil
You didn't post the listing and I'm too unawake to check it out right now, but it sounds from the other comments as if it's on target. It struck me as Ms Lavingne too – very skater, from the word go.
But you want honesty, right? I personally think your verse is perfect – great premise, great lyric, vocal, everything... But the pre-chorus could be much stronger, IMHO. The prosody feels like it's one beat off, do you know what I mean?. It doesn't quite follow the rhythm of real speech, to my ears. And you know what I keep hearing everywhere? – put in some nonsense syllables. Seems like you have the ideal opporyunity here. The first 'You're No Fun' is great, but why not do a communal 'Whoa oh oh, oh oh oh' on the C, G#, F#, instead of repeating the first line? Like, all the gang, you know?
Do appreciate that all of this is just my opinion, and I've no idea what your deadline is for this, but to my mind this is a song with all kinds of potential beyond this particular listings, and if this was mine I'd try to hone it more, get it as good as it can be. I'm convinced the long-term patoff will make it worth the while.
All said in the spirit of support, I hope you understand, not judgement, and only my 2-cents' worth. Best of luck with it, whatever route you take. Good song. Good luck.
Nick
Re: Teeny Pop for S111209PO - feedback please!
Posted: Mon Dec 12, 2011 9:04 am
by NeilEbanks
nick.moxsom wrote:The first 'You're No Fun' is great, but why not do a communal 'Whoa oh oh, oh oh oh' on the C, G#, F#, instead of repeating the first line? Like, all the gang, you know?
Hey Nick. I'm not sure what you mean with the Whoa oh ohs. It sounds cool, but I guess I'd have to hear it.
Thank you for putting thoughts into it and sharing them. Much appreciated.
Re: Teeny Pop for S111209PO - feedback please!
Posted: Mon Dec 12, 2011 12:40 pm
by nick.moxsom
Sorry, dude, I didn't make myself clear.
The girl sings "You're no fun", then it's repeated twice by the b/vox. If those three nores were "oh"s each time it would sound cool, I think. Just my thoughts...
HTH,
Nick
Re: Teeny Pop for S111209PO - feedback please!
Posted: Mon Dec 12, 2011 1:53 pm
by NeilEbanks
Oh, right on! I'll definitely bounce that around. Thanks Nick!