Hi all,
There are times that they can't license (or maybe can't afford to license) a track by a major artist, yet they still want the same sonic texture and emotion for the scene. They need the same tempo, a similar compliment of instruments, a similar vocal sound, maybe the same number of singers (bkgs or just solo), and they probably need a similar topic or at least category of topic for the lyric.
There's not a library or film/TV publisher in the business that wouldn't love to have a pile of that stuff. Why? Because a director says to the music supervisor, "Get me something that sounds kinda like Ray LaMontagne for that breakup scene."
The music supervisor turns to their favorite suppliers. If the suppliers don't have it, they turn to TAXI. The smart suppliers (libraries and pubs) ANTICIPATE needs based on recent trends and build a stash of what they think will be popular in the near and mid future.
Check out Paul Otten's song "Let You Down" on this page:
http://www.taximusic.com/hosting/home.php?userid=1674
Who does that sound like? What song does it remind you of? Does it rip anybody off? No. Could it be playing on a jukebox in the background of a scene and make the viewers FEEL like they've heard a certain band? Yes!
Paul's song is actually closer to a soundalike than inspired by or an a la because it was targeted at a particular song. But if the instruments were the same, and the tempo was the same, and the vocal ATTITUDE was the same without some of the close approximations of the ooh, ooh, oohs, it would probably fall under an a la.
Oftentimes, the music supervisors have to be very careful in how they word their requests (as do we) for legal reasons. That's why they give a "range" or throw in an etc. Other times, they are looking for music/artists that sound like they could be played on the same radio station or be touring on the same bill together. Are they in a RANGE that would appeal to the same listener?
In the end, most of the time, they want similar sonic textures and lyric themes/topics to fill a space where a particular artist or song popped into their head.
HTH,
Michael