Common Ground

[billman]

would love to get some honest feedback on 2 tunes:Alive (Rock)Bye Bye Maggie (Acoustic)http://www.taximusic.com/hosting/home.p ... illmanI've received forwards and rejections on both tunes and received complete polar opposite feedback replies on both. Just wanting to get some feedback if possible.thanks -- billman

[jchitty]

I wish I could critique everyone's song here, but I'm short on time...I see a lot of people here who I'd love to listen to their stuff. I just listened to "Bye Bye Maggie" and I really like it....this must be the night for 70's type songs....(I know you're inspired by Foo Fighters, etc though) but don't see that as bad....this has an "America" (the group of course) feel to it....it takes me back....good work!

[billman]

Oct 29, 2008, 4:39pm, jchitty wrote:I wish I could critique everyone's song here, but I'm short on time...I see a lot of people here who I'd love to listen to their stuff. I just listened to "Bye Bye Maggie" and I really like it....this must be the night for 70's type songs....(I know you're inspired by Foo Fighters, etc though) but don't see that as bad....this has an "America" (the group of course) feel to it....it takes me back....good work!thanks! yeah, that tune is more laid back with a singer/songwriter feel and a little different than many of our other songs.