What is a Good Critique

[Hookjaw Brown]

Had a custom critique done on Cheers to Mother Earth (on my Taxi music page). It is a Ska Pot Song and I have no expectations of ever placing it on Taxi. I am using it as an entry in all the Hempfests going around, plus a Cheech and Chong movie, and some intros on Medical Marijuana sites.

The listener gave 9's across the board!

I was curious as to what others get from their critiques. How good is good?

[gtrmann]

Hello Le Hook,
I did the custom critique about a year ago with one of my best songs so far ( IMHO ) and I received 5s, 6s, and 7s ....

[davewalton]

Had a custom critique done on Cheers to Mother Earth (on my Taxi music page). It is a Ska Pot Song and I have no expectations of ever placing it on Taxi. I am using it as an entry in all the Hempfests going around, plus a Cheech and Chong movie, and some intros on Medical Marijuana sites.

The listener gave 9's across the board!

Maybe the listener got into the theme of the song, lit up, settled back and enjoyed the music!

I don't know about custom stuff but on average I get 8's... maybe more 9's than 7's and I'm happy with that. The 9's across the board if that's kind of a consistent theme, to me means that you can enjoy the pleasure of focusing on the songwriting since the other things (like production, etc) are all good.

BTW... that's a really brilliant targeting of music, it really is.

[fusilierb]

Had a custom critique done on Cheers to Mother Earth (on my Taxi music page). It is a Ska Pot Song and I have no expectations of ever placing it on Taxi. I am using it as an entry in all the Hempfests going around, plus a Cheech and Chong movie, and some intros on Medical Marijuana sites.

The listener gave 9's across the board!

BTW... that's a really brilliant targeting of music, it really is.

+1