The good review no forward

[Piewackit1]

This is for the Cold Play, Snow Patrol listing. I got a return on this one but #362 thought highly of the song. He gave me all 9s. Going to wait to submit it for a darker Alt rock listing, if it ever comes.

This is what #362 said about my song:

Thanks so much for submitting this song. Unfortunately, I don't think it quite works for this particular listing.

Every thing about your track is top notch. It's the right style. It's well recorded. I like the movement in the melody.

My concern comes in that it's a little pensive and dark times. It does not come across as undeniably happy at all times. This listing wanted songs that were "positive and optimistic" and wasn't the feeling I was left with 100 percent. There was a bit of uncertainty there.


Here is the song if you want to listen. https://soundcloud.com/piewackit-1/02-pie-mood-ring