Listing:"No prominent melodies at all." Feedback: "Melody could be stronger"

[Casey H]

I call that opportunity!

....or perhaps missed opportunity. If the original submission and the feedback had been posted as suggested, more specific help would have been offered on how it might satisfy the listing requirements.

True. But I meant in general. Anyone who got a return from the first listing can use the feedback and try again. Happy New Year!

[superblonde]

....or perhaps missed opportunity. If the original submission and the feedback had been posted as suggested, more specific help would have been offered on how it might satisfy the listing requirements.

Any feedback would have been misdirection since every TAXI submitter "got it wrong".

[Casey H]

....or perhaps missed opportunity. If the original submission and the feedback had been posted as suggested, more specific help would have been offered on how it might satisfy the listing requirements.

Any feedback would have been misdirection since every TAXI submitter "got it wrong".

That makes zero sense. The feedback tells you why you got it wrong, from the screener's POV. Taxi didn't say no tracks were forwarded. The client said they didn't find what they were looking for. This happens sometimes. It's like 50 actors being called in for an audition but the movie folks didn't think any of them were right for the part.

If I recall, you never posted a link to your track and the critique. In the absence of that, it's really hard to hold a meaningful discussion.

One can be totally negative or use the opportunity to try to make it a positive.

Casey