Idle Idol Chatter

[Casey H]

i really wish the judges would give a little constructive criticism. "it was amazing, it was beautiful" is getting pretty old.

I agree, Juliet. It's gone from overly insulting (Simon) to sickeningly sweet. I think even *I* could sing up there and get compliments from Steven Tyler.

I had enough of Randy's "Yo..... Yo.... Yo, man"... I didn't watch this week. I lost interest. I think J.Lo is the best of the three.

Casey

[michael11]

It was almost impossible to add my post without sneaking a look at anybody else's.


But I had to say it.


Hayley gave the performance of the series!!!!

We get the result tomorrow.

[michael11]

C,mon America Be Honest


Did Jacob get too camp for ya?????


He did for me!!!!

[hazineju]

Michael11 - don't read this till you've watched the results show (i mention one of the bottom two)

Hayley did knock House of the Rising Sun out of the park. what i really admire about this girl (other than her chops) is she really believes in herself and she is a fighter. she's been in the bottom two so many times, and probably gotten the most criticism from the judges, but she hasn't let it get her down. you could see she was bummed with the critique after her first performance but she just came back out and rocked her second song. that really takes some inner strength. poor Lauren on the other hand turned into a basket case last night when she hit the bottom two for the first time. it really showed her age and lack of confidence. i think Hayley is a great example of the determination and belief in yourself that you need to keep your head above water in this biz.

i think Scotty is going to win though

[michael11]

Michael11 - don't read this till you've watched the results show (i mention one of the bottom two)

Hayley did knock House of the Rising Sun out of the park. what i really admire about this girl (other than her chops) is she really believes in herself and she is a fighter. she's been in the bottom two so many times, and probably gotten the most criticism from the judges, but she hasn't let it get her down. you could see she was bummed with the critique after her first performance but she just came back out and rocked her second song. that really takes some inner strength. poor Lauren on the other hand turned into a basket case last night when she hit the bottom two for the first time. it really showed her age and lack of confidence. i think Hayley is a great example of the determination and belief in yourself that you need to keep your head above water in this biz.

i think Scotty is going to win though

Thanks haz for being so considerate and warning me before I might have read something that would have spoilt it for me.

I absolutly agree with you on everything except the final result.

I really really like Scotty but I don't know if I agree with you about him being the eventual winner.

[hazineju]

one word for tonight's results show:

lame!

yet another idol disappointment

[michael11]

one word for tonight's results show:

lame!

yet another idol disappointment

Oh Dear!


I don't get the results till tonight,in about eight hours,this is how it seemed to me.

James,

Haley,Scotty,Lauren.

Not my preference but just based on performance.

If Haley has gone I'm gonna stop watching!


Till next week.

[michael11]

ooooooopppppppppppps

I know who went out!

I am surprised but I didn't like him much.



He just used to scream in tune.

[DesireeBowen]

I really hope Hayley wins this thing. She has such an interesting voice. And I like her personality.

I have to admit, I've been holding a grudge against Scotty since he was mean to that kid at Hollywood week. He just reminds me of the popular baseball kid in HS who was a complete jerk.

[michael11]

I really hope Hayley wins this thing. She has such an interesting voice. And I like her personality.

I have to admit, I've been holding a grudge against Scotty since he was mean to that kid at Hollywood week. He just reminds me of the popular baseball kid in HS who was a complete jerk.

I've noticed week by week Scotty is getting a bit big for his cowboy boots.